The Problem of Attention
It’s very difficult to give attention, support, and feedback to students in different locations. Having some students on a video conference and other students in person means that a number of students are not getting your full attention at any one time. Teachers may initially find it challenging to facilitate learning, monitor the room, and monitor Zoom all at the same time.
The Problem of Variety
Experienced teachers understand that using a variety of modalities during a lesson is vital to engaging students. A concurrent classroom may present a unique set of challenges, as transitions may be difficult for a teacher using this model.
Barrington 220 teachers have made many breakthroughs during distance learning, and much of what we’ve learned about new ways to facilitate high-level learning will carry over to the hybrid model.
Recently, Barrington High School iDAL coach, Jeff Spella, and Assistant Principal, Ben Rodriguez, worked to identify the instructional modalities that might make the most sense when teaching students in person and at home. We have identified six modalities that worked effectively in a concurrent classroom setting using our technology devices and services. We borrowed a classroom at the high school (thanks Lauren Schoepp) and tested them out. Here is a brief description of the modalities we tried, followed by some thoughts on what we learned.
Whole-Group Discussion
- At-home students could hear surprisingly well when only the teacher’s computer was set up for sound. The teacher’s mic and projector’s speaker were sufficient for sound.
- When leading a group discussion, the teacher may have all in-person students on a Zoom conference or participating through the teacher’s device. The only drawback we could see to not having in-person students on the Zoom is that at-home students can’t see them.
- If in-person students are on the Zoom, they should join without audio by selecting “cancel” when prompted to join with audio. The microphone and speakers on the teacher’s device will be the only one’s using audio in the room.
- The teacher’s microphone should be enough to pick up everyone in the room, but enabling audio on a second or third student device may be needed depending on the size of the room. In this case, the few students who join with audio should mute during the session unless someone near to them is speaking. This will likely not be needed in most classrooms, but might be effective in a larger space such as a library or gym.
- To hear at-home students, the teacher should project to the SMART Board or other large screen in the room.
- Two teacher devices are recommended for this setup: one device for managing the Zoom, and one for delivering the lesson. After several trials, it seems to work best to have a MacBook Air laptop as the Zoom device, and an iPad as the teaching device.
- On the Zoom device, the teacher should follow the same setup as “whole group discussion”.
- The teacher should then join the conference on a second device as a co-host (iPad is recommended) and screen-share to teach from this device. By projecting from the MacBook Air laptop and screen sharing from iPad, you are essentially projecting from your teaching device, giving you more flexibility.
- If a teacher is doing a live demonstration, it is recommended that you use an digital whiteboard rather than the physical whiteboard in the room. Trials showed us that at-home students will see much better with a digital whiteboard such as Google’s Jamboard.
- Location-specific conferencing seems to be the easiest to set up. In this modality, in-person students meet with other in-person students, and at-home students meet with other at-home students.
- The teacher can use Zoom to manage Breakout Rooms for at-home students while physically monitoring discussions in class. In-person students should temporarily leave the Zoom during these discussions.
- For mixed-location group conferencing, we recommend Google Hangouts. The audio logistics for a Zoom proved difficult to manage. If teachers want to have in-class students to meet with at-home students in small groups, they should leave the Zoom and initiate their own Google Hangouts. This makes it easier for students to connect and manage their conversations, but makes it harder for teachers to monitor at-home students. While teachers will see the reactions of the in-class students, they will not see or hear the at-home students.